Difference between revisions of "EB: GOTTSCHALK v. BENSON, 409 U.S. 63 (1972)"

From Bill Goodwine's Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 12: Line 12:
 
**Benson's patent would "wholly pre-empt the mathematical formula and in practical effect would be a patent on the algorithm itself."
 
**Benson's patent would "wholly pre-empt the mathematical formula and in practical effect would be a patent on the algorithm itself."
 
***In other words, Benson's patent is for a mathematical formula/algorithm, and these are ruled to be ideas, which alone are not patentable
 
***In other words, Benson's patent is for a mathematical formula/algorithm, and these are ruled to be ideas, which alone are not patentable
*Important outcome: You can't patent a computer program
+
*Important outcome: You can't patent a computer program (as of 1972)

Revision as of 12:43, 7 February 2011

The Situation

  • Benson develops a "method for converting numerical information from binary-coded decimal numbers into pure binary numbers."
  • Gottschalk is the commissioner of patents who originally rejected the patent, Benson appealed and won - Supreme Court grants centiorari

Decision

  • Benson's patent is invalid (sustaining the examiners original decision, but reversing the Appeals court decision)

Reasoning

  • You can't patent an idea - if you discover a "phenomenon of nature" you can't claim a monopoly on it unless you apply the law of nature to a "new and useful end"
    • The claims of Benson's patent were sweeping - claiming all rights to the process developed (whether by a computer or by hand)
  • A process is patentable if it transforms or reduces the subject matter to a "different state or thing"
    • Benson's patent would "wholly pre-empt the mathematical formula and in practical effect would be a patent on the algorithm itself."
      • In other words, Benson's patent is for a mathematical formula/algorithm, and these are ruled to be ideas, which alone are not patentable
  • Important outcome: You can't patent a computer program (as of 1972)