Difference between revisions of "Notes"

From Bill Goodwine's Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 5: Line 5:
  
 
Device:  designed to absorb shock from plow shanks in rocky soil to prevent damage to the plow
 
Device:  designed to absorb shock from plow shanks in rocky soil to prevent damage to the plow
 +
 +
1955 - 5th circuit says valid -  "old result in a cheaper and otherwise more advantageous way."
 +
1966 - 8th circuit says invalid - no new result in the combination

Revision as of 01:03, 4 February 2011

  • Non-obviousness

Argued October 14, 1965. Decided February 21, 1966

Petitioner: Graham - sues John Deere for patent infringement

Device: designed to absorb shock from plow shanks in rocky soil to prevent damage to the plow

1955 - 5th circuit says valid - "old result in a cheaper and otherwise more advantageous way." 1966 - 8th circuit says invalid - no new result in the combination